Comparitive Analysis of Turbidity and Organics Removal in Biological Activated Carbon and Anthracite-Sand Filters in the Moorhead Water Treatment Plant

Abstract

The source water for the Moorhead Water Treatment Plant (MWTP) exhibits high concentrations of total organic carbon (TOC) throughout the year and seasonal taste and odor (T&O) events. To prevent biological regrowth in the distribution system there is a need to improve organics removal in the existing biological anthracite-sand filters, especially during cold water conditions when a significant decrease in removal efficiencies are observed. Three types of granular activated carbon (GAC) were selected for a pilot study to evaluate the potential of enhanced organics and T&O removal in biological activated carbon (BAC) filters compared to anthracite-sand. Turbidity removal was also evaluated to ensure regulatory requirements could be met with BAC filters. The overall performance of the BAC filters demonstrated a significant improvement over anthracite-sand. The bituminous coal-based GACs outperformed the coconut-based GAC and exhibited surface characteristics which may have a significant impact on the removal of organics, T&O, and turbidity.